Maxanti - A logic puzzle
-4 points by bronlund
-4 points by bronlund
I vibecoded a puzzle game for a math professor friend of mine as a birthday present. He seemed to like it, so I am sharing it with all you guys as well. My friend enjoy figuring things out by himself, for him it's part of the puzzle, so the manual link provided below was not initially given to him.
The game has no ads, no cookies, no analytics - the server doesn't even write an access log. That being said, I have really no idea of what's going on inside the code, I have not read any of it or done any proper review. The model used was Fable 5.2 on high effort, and the project was done in an afternoon and ended up using about 11m tokens. It was designed as a mobile first PWA project using a Bauhaus inspired theme. The size of the download is about 200KB.
The game: https://maxanti.com
The manual: https://maxanti.com/help
GLHF
Could do with a dark mode:
his instruction is a bit vague.
A clue has a kind and a value. The four kinds are h0, h1, h2 and h3. Each kind looks at the stones in another way.
h0 counts the stones.
h1 compares opposite sides of the clue.
h2 compares the three pairs of opposite cells.
h3 compares every second cell with the other three cells.
I don't know how to parse - h1-h3 as an instruction even by experimenting with it to understand how they work.
I don't mind getting flagged, I am not really selling anything - I just wanted to share.
I suggest you browse through the manual at https://maxanti.com/help to understand what's going on. Playing it without reading the manual is kind of like playing Sudoku without knowing the rules of Sudoku. The in-game instructions was designed to be vague (my instructions by the way).
You can change to dark mode in the settings. On desktop, it's kind of stupid I know, the menu is down right. It looks better on mobile.
It's an interesting idea, but it doesn't quite work for me.
A really important part of game and puzzle design is iconography. The tiny little h# is really hard to read, and to understand. And sqrt(3) is rather opaque. Instead, h0 could be a raw number. h2 could be a delta with the ordered pairs (0,0), (0,1), (0,2), and (1,2) instead of 0,1,2,sqrt(3). h3 could be a six-pointed asterisk, representing the three pairs, with a number.
Admittedly, I can't imagine what icons could distill the six-row h1 table. I'm sure there's a mathematical reason why there are two cases for h1=1, but I can't imagine that anyone who is not familiar with whatever area of math this is will ever figure it out. If you can't think of an icon, or at least a much shorter explanation, it's probably not actually a reasonable rule for humans.
I feel like there's a tension between having thousands of levels and having the player figure out the rules. Those are two different games (Covert Action Rule). For the figure-out-the-rules game, you want a level progression that eases you into the rules, one baby step at a time. Take a look at Patrick's Parabox (and listen to his talk from Metagame 2025 if it's online) for a great example of this. For the thousands of levels game, you still need a progression but you explain each new thing (h3, h2, h1) as it comes up, and you make the complete rules available at any time. In either case, you don't need all of hint stuff from the rules.
(And of course the AI prose is ... rather load-bearing, if you know what I mean)
Thank you for taking the time to give me feedback, I really appreciate that. There's a little bit to unpack there, so I can't give you any reply to your input right now, but rest assured I will comb through it. And kudos for the references!
And, yeah, I know what you mean.
Oh, now I see the math. You could make it so clicking on a clue displays the arrows in adjacent cells.
Consider h2 1 with two dots marked on opposite sides, and one open space (the rest being either clues or marked empty). Either filling the open space, or marking it empty, will turn the cell red. So why isn't it already red?
Aha, I think I figured out h1! 0 is "balanced", sqrt(3) is one or two pair, 2 is 3-in-a-row, and 1 is everything else. This seems like a set of things that icons could convey!
Do I understand it correctly that you are playing this without having read the manual? If you do, is it intentional or did I fumble this by not being clear about the fact that the real manual is not in the game, but at https://maxanti.com/help
The manual was too long and AI, so I just skipped to the part that explained the meanings of h#. Later, I found the table, which is much easier to reference. There's sort of a chunking problem -- thirteen is a lot of cases to memorize. My game Deco Deck has the same problem; I ultimately added a button to display a quick reference.
BTW, have you played Bombe? I had to uninstall it because I have a hard time with impulse control, but I like the way it makes the game feel large but finite. Not sure how it would work here, since the rules are so complicated.